A counterparty in a conversion center case:
When the BEB (Economic Security Bureau) exposes a conversion center, the case rarely ends with its organizers. In 2026, the bureau twice reported more than 200 enterprises that used the services of such centers, and representatives of the “real sector” have already received notices of suspicion.
Behind each such enterprise stands a director, an accountant, and an owner, all asking the same thing: what will happen to us now? Below, I write about what the investigation will have to prove against a buyer, where the defense has real arguments, and when paying taxes releases a person from liability.
After a conversion center, they come for the buyers
A conversion center is a network of controlled companies and FOPs (individual entrepreneurs) through which non-cash money is turned into cash, while buyers receive documents for supplies. In 2026, the BEB reported on several such networks.
- April 2026. A conversion center with a turnover of up to UAH 18 billion and about 500 controlled companies and FOPs. According to the BEB, more than 200 enterprises reduced their VAT through it. Notices of suspicion went not only to the organizers but also to “representatives of the real sector of the economy.”
- September 2026. A network of conversion centers through which UAH 23.5 billion has passed since 2023. According to the bureau, 200 enterprises used it, including in the fuel sector.
What a case against a client, that is, a buyer of such firms’ “services,” looks like is shown by the BEB’s October report on an agricultural company. According to the investigation, the company bought products for cash from unidentified persons, while its accounts showed purchases from firms that supplied nothing. The director, according to the BEB, approved the search for such suppliers, signed contracts with them, and confirmed payments. He received a notice of suspicion under Part 3 of Article 212 of the Criminal Code.
The amount, almost UAH 42 million for 2021-2025, is supported by a tax inspection report and a forensic examination. The losses were reimbursed, and the case went to court with a motion for release from liability.
The logic can be seen in these cases. Documents and storage devices seized at the conversion center, together with the register of tax invoices, show who received documents from the controlled firms. Then come an inspection, a report, an examination, and a suspicion for the person who signed contracts and reports.
Three different situations behind one word, “client”
The first thing I do in such cases is work out which kind of client the company was. The words “the goods were real” are heard in every case, but they mean different things.
- The goods came from the named supplier, and the buyer did not know about its violations. The main question is what confirms the delivery and the buyer’s good faith.
- The goods came from other persons, and the documents were issued through a technical company. This is exactly the scheme the BEB describes in the agricultural company case. Here you need to establish who actually supplied the goods, which costs are proven, and what the consequences are separately for VAT and corporate income tax. The amount depends on this, and therefore so does the legal classification.
- There was no delivery: the money was transferred and returned in cash. Here the defense is built entirely differently. The prosecution will have to prove the return of funds, the participation of a specific person, their intent, and the amount.
Which situation the company falls into determines the main decision for the business: to defend or to pay. So the situation must be assessed honestly, and before the investigation assesses it.
What must be proven against a buyer
Tax debt is not yet a crime in itself. For Article 212 of the Criminal Code, the prosecution must prove three things: the method of evasion, the direct intent of a specific person, and the amount of unpaid taxes for a specific period.
Direct intent means that the person was aware of the non-payment of tax and wanted it. A director’s signature on contracts and reports is only one piece of evidence and does not create automatic guilt.
The Supreme Court reminds us of this regularly. In September 2026, the Criminal Cassation Court upheld an acquittal in a case on non-payment of land tax (No. 750/8892/23): non-payment alone does not prove intentional evasion. The court separately noted that fines and penalties are not included in the amount of unpaid tax on which the legal classification depends. This is not a conversion center case, but the logic is the same.
The second important question is where the amount comes from. In case No. 583/2063/16-k (January 2025), the charge against the director relied, among other things, on an unlawful tax inspection. The prosecutor tried to confirm the amount with his own compilation of documents, but the Supreme Court left the acquittal in force.
For me, this extends a simple thesis: an analytical report or an investigation’s calculation is a version of events, not evidence.
The third is the fate of the counterparty itself. Fictitious entrepreneurship (formerly Article 205 of the Criminal Code) has not been a crime since 2019. But this does not make technical firms lawful: using such a counterparty can become a method of evasion if the buyer’s intent is proven.
In a tax dispute, the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court as early as 2022 (No. 160/3364/19) stated that an enterprise with signs of fictitiousness remains a subject of law. A verdict against its director does not resolve the buyer’s dispute if it contains no facts about the buyer’s own actions. The court must assess the primary documents, the ability to carry out the operation, and its connection with the taxpayer’s activity.
In April 2026, the Cassation Administrative Court applied this approach in a case on sunflower oil supplies (No. 520/525/20): problems at earlier links of the supply chain do not in themselves refute the buyer’s operations.
At the same time, flawlessly executed documents do not help if the facts contradict them. In May 2025, the Cassation Administrative Court rejected a taxpayer’s appeal (No. 440/3111/19). The court took into account transport documents, the carriers’ denials, and the fact that the counterparty’s signatory was abroad.
For the buyer, the decisive question is this: can the company show what exactly it received, from whom, and what it paid for.
A tax dispute and a criminal case: coordinate from day one
A PPR, that is, a tax assessment notice, is the document by which the tax authority determines additional tax liabilities. The amount in it usually becomes the amount in the suspicion. So appealing a PPR makes sense not only for the sake of taxes.
In March 2026, the Criminal Cassation Court upheld an acquittal of a director and a chief accountant (No. 758/9/18). The PPRs on the VAT and corporate income tax amounts they were charged with had been finally canceled, and the panel linked this to the absence of objective elements of Article 212 of the Criminal Code.
But I would not present this as a simple rule of “win the tax dispute and close the criminal case.” In 2025, in another case (No. 707/472/18), the Supreme Court overturned the closure of proceedings and stated that an administrative decision cannot automatically be given prejudicial effect.
And on 17 September 2026, a panel of the Criminal Cassation Court in that same case referred to the joint chamber the question of whether cancellation of a PPR excludes the elements of Article 212 of the Criminal Code. A referral does not yet mean a change of position, but there is still no final answer.
So I advise against waiting for one proceeding to end before starting the other. Tax appeals and criminal defense must be coordinated from the start. Objections to an inspection report, explanations from the accounting department, and the position in the administrative court will later become part of the criminal case.
Cancellation of additional assessments can significantly strengthen the defense under Article 212 of the Criminal Code. But its weight depends on the grounds for cancellation and the evidence in the criminal proceedings.
When payment releases from liability
Part 4 of Article 212 of the Criminal Code provides a way out that many companies use. A person is released from liability if, before being brought to criminal liability, they paid the taxes, financial sanctions, and penalties. Being brought to liability begins with a notice of suspicion, so the window for such a decision is open only until the suspicion.
The Supreme Court’s 2026 practice shows how important the details are here. In case No. 521/3296/25, almost UAH 7.4 million of VAT was paid before the suspicion. The prosecutor objected to release because the fines and penalties had not been paid. But he failed to provide timely evidence that such sanctions had been assessed at all, and in June 2026 the Supreme Court left the release in force.
I do not read this ruling as a rule that “paying just the tax is enough.” The conclusion for business is simpler: pay in full, and have every payment and every assessment confirmed by documents.
The second trap is the amount itself. I do not advise paying the first figure named. First you need to understand what it rests on: an inspection report and an examination, or an analytical report. And in a “the goods are real, the supplier is not” situation, also check whether it was calculated correctly, separately for VAT and corporate income tax.
The third is scale and time. In 2026, liability under Article 212 of the Criminal Code arises from UAH 4.992 million in unpaid taxes; a large amount starts at UAH 8.320 million, and an especially large amount at UAH 11.648 million. For episodes of earlier years, the thresholds are different, since they are calculated using the indicators of the time.
And the limitation period for Parts 2 and 3 of Article 212 of the Criminal Code is 10 years, so operations from past years will remain in the risk zone for a long time.
What a company should do right now
The time between the exposure of a conversion center and a visit to its client is time for a decision. If your company worked with suppliers that could have ended up in such a network, I advise the following order.
- Determine which of the three situations each disputed operation falls into. All further strategy depends on this.
- Check counterparties through public traces. Rulings of investigating judges on temporary access and attachments concerning suppliers often appear in the register of court decisions before any requests to you.
- Gather evidence of the reality of operations and honestly look for contradictions in it. Consignment notes (TTN), warehouse records, transportation, correspondence, and subsequent use of the goods. It is better to find contradictions yourself than to hear about them from an investigator.
- Document how the counterparty was chosen. Checking the Unified State Register and VAT payer status is the minimum, but not a guarantee. The court will assess the whole set of circumstances.
- Run tax and criminal defense as one team. Objections to the report are written with an eye to how the investigator will read them.
- If the liability is real, pay in full and before the suspicion. Taxes, sanctions, and penalties, with documents for each amount. But only after checking what the amount itself rests on.
- Prepare your people. The director and the accountant who signed contracts and reports will be the first to receive summonses for questioning. They must know their rights and have a lawyer from the very first one.
The exposure of a conversion center does not make every one of its counterparties a criminal. But it places on the company a practical duty to present its operations in such a way that the investigation’s version does not become the only one.
In such cases, whoever understands their situation earlier has the most options: to prove the reality of the operations or to pay taxes in full and on time.
