FOP networks after Draft Law No. 16150:
“Is this already a scheme or not yet?”
This is the question many owners now ask themselves when their business operates through several FOPs (individual entrepreneurs):
- a chain of stores where each outlet is registered to a separate entrepreneur;
- a service company where part of the team works as FOPs;
- a family business split among relatives.
For years, such models were considered ordinary tax optimization.
In 2026, the situation has changed. The BEB (Economic Security Bureau) opens cases against such structures under Article 212 of the Criminal Code, conducts searches, and serves notices of suspicion. The tax authority publishes lists of “signs of splitting.”
And on 15 October, the government submitted Draft Law No. 16150 to the Verkhovna Rada, which introduces a general rule against tax abuse.
At the same time, the law still has no answer to the main question: when are several FOPs several businesses, and when are they one business hiding from taxes?
In this article, I look at four questions:
- which rules apply now and how the BEB works under them;
- what Draft Law No. 16150 will change for FOP networks;
- what BEB cases will rest on after it;
- which decisions a business can make right now.
1. What applies now: the rules and BEB cases
What the law says
I will start with a fact that is often forgotten. The Tax Code contains no concept of “business splitting,” no separate penalty for it, and no separate article in the Criminal Code.
When a business operates through several FOPs, each of which is registered and pays the single tax, this is lawful in itself.
In July, Deputy Minister of Finance Svitlana Vorobei expressly acknowledged this: splitting is not a crime in itself, so criteria are needed to distinguish a lawful division of a business from a tax evasion scheme.
Criminal liability arises under Article 212 of the Criminal Code, that is, for intentional tax evasion. The article itself does not say which taxes must be paid or in what amount; it refers to the Tax Code.
In 2026, it is applied from UAH 4.992 million in unpaid taxes, and an especially large amount starts at UAH 11.648 million.
How the BEB operates
The BEB classifies splitting as evasion under Article 212 of the Criminal Code and reports such cases regularly in 2026.
- Mykolaiv region. A chain of mini-markets operated through 17 FOPs: relatives, acquaintances, and former employees. The investigation calculated a turnover of almost UAH 84 million and underpayment of over UAH 11.6 million, and the owner was served a notice of suspicion under Part 3 of Article 212 of the Criminal Code.
- Odesa. According to the BEB, a flower business channeled money through more than 30 FOPs. The entrepreneur returned UAH 10.6 million to the budget and transferred another UAH 1 million to the Armed Forces.
- A chain of second-hand stores. In May, 23 searches were conducted at a chain linked to more than 530 FOPs.
These cases show what detectives look at. Taken separately, no single sign proves anything, but together they add up to a picture of “one business”:
- one person makes decisions and controls the money of all the FOPs;
- the entrepreneurs are relatives or employees who in fact manage nothing;
- revenue is distributed so that no FOP exceeds the single tax limit;
- shared staff, brand, warehouse and premises, and identical types of activity;
- identical IP addresses used to log in to electronic accounts, client-bank systems, and software cash registers (RRO).
The investigation calculates the “losses” as if the entire business should have been a single taxpayer on the general system. That is why BEB notices speak of VAT and corporate income tax, not the single tax.
For a network with a turnover in the tens of millions, the thresholds of Article 212 of the Criminal Code are reached quickly.
Many cases end with the owner fully reimbursing the amount calculated by the investigation. But quick payment does not mean the amount was calculated correctly.
What the courts say
There is relevant Supreme Court case law, but it does not establish a universal test by which any structure of several FOPs can be recognized as a crime. Four positions matter for the defense.
- Intent must be proven. Non-payment of tax does not in itself prove guilt, and the conclusions of tax authorities do not in themselves prove intent (Criminal Cassation Court of the Supreme Court, ruling of 18.01.2022, No. 711/1481/20). The prosecution must prove direct intent, that is, that the person was aware of the non-payment and wanted it, beyond reasonable doubt (Criminal Cassation Court of the Supreme Court, ruling of 09.11.2022, No. 604/597/16).
- The criminal case depends on the tax case. A tax assessment notice (PPR) is the document by which the tax authority determines additional tax liabilities. If an administrative court has overturned it, the inspection report is no longer proper evidence of non-payment (Criminal Cassation Court of the Supreme Court, ruling of 13.12.2022, No. 464/6127/18).
- A network of FOPs in a tax dispute. In case No. 600/1052/20-a, the tax authority linked a company’s income to sales through FOPs and shared IP addresses, and relied on materials from the criminal proceedings. The Supreme Court noted that such materials are not binding on the administrative court, that interrogation records are not proper evidence before a verdict, and that an inspection report must refer to specific primary documents.
- FOP status does not disappear “by itself.” The registration of a single tax payer can be canceled only by a separate decision of the tax authority following an inspection, and the conditions of the simplified system are interpreted literally (Cassation Administrative Court of the Supreme Court, ruling of 11.08.2026, No. 320/46652/23).
Where the prosecution is weak
Today, the Tax Code does not give the tax authority the right to “merge” several FOPs into a single taxpayer: there are no criteria, no procedure, and no decision by which such a merger would be formalized.
But the investigation already calculates VAT and corporate income tax as if the merger had taken place. In my opinion, criminal prosecution here gets ahead of the tax rule on which it should rest.
Moreover, the amount is often taken from analytical reports, without an inspection or a PPR. This summer, the Business Ombudsman Council publicly pointed out that proceedings under Article 212 of the Criminal Code are opened even before tax liabilities are agreed.
BEB analytics is the investigation’s version of events, not evidence.
For the owner, this gap has a practical cost: a search, seizure of cash registers and servers, and freezing of accounts can stop a network within days. That is why people often pay not because they agree with the calculation, but because the business cannot wait.
At the same time, I am not claiming that any network of FOPs is lawful. If the “entrepreneurs” know nothing about their business, and the money from their accounts returns to one person, the investigation has something to prove.
The line runs not at the number of FOPs, but at whether each of them genuinely conducts its own activity: makes decisions, bears costs and risks, and receives its own income.
2. Draft Law No. 16150: new rules for FOP networks
On 14 October, the government approved Draft Law No. 16150, and on 15 October it registered it in the Verkhovna Rada. It transposes into the Tax Code the rules of the EU Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD).
The word “splitting” does not appear in it, but it gives the tax authority a new tool for exactly such situations.
What will be considered abuse
The main novelty is a general rule against tax abuse, the new Article 395 of the Tax Code. An operation or a set of operations will be considered abuse if two conditions are met at the same time:
- purpose: the main purpose, or one of the main purposes, is a tax advantage that runs contrary to the purpose of the Tax Code’s provisions;
- artificiality: the operation has no valid commercial reasons reflecting economic reality.
A tax advantage will be understood as any opportunity to pay less.
There is an important exception. An operation that produces a tax advantage will not be abuse if it corresponds to the purpose of the provision that grants that advantage.
For FOPs this is fundamental: the simplified system is itself a lawful benefit. The question will be not whether a business uses the single tax, but whether a specific structure corresponds to the purpose of the simplified system.
How a network of FOPs will be assessed
The key concept will be the set of operations. Several operations will be considered together if they are aimed at one common result or if one is impossible without another.
So the registration of several entrepreneurs, the contracts between them, and the distribution of revenue “to fit the limits” can be assessed by the tax authority as a single set. It will disregard the artificial part of the operations and replace it with operations that reflect the real substance of the parties’ relationship.
Put simply, if one business in fact stands behind several FOPs, the tax authority will be able to calculate taxes based on that substance. At the same time, the consequences will be determined separately for each taxpayer, taking into account the facts established specifically with respect to that taxpayer.
What this means for FOPs themselves
The draft provides separate rules for entrepreneurs:
- funds and property received as a result of abuse will be taxed with the single tax at a rate of 18% (the usual rate for the third group is 5%);
- the FOP must switch to the general system from the first day of the month following the quarter in which the abuse occurred;
- registering as a single tax payer will not be possible if the abuse occurred in the current year or the two preceding years;
- fines and penalties will be charged on general grounds;
- the tax authority will be able to review such operations for 2,555 days, about 7 years, rather than the usual 1,095 days.
How the procedure will work
In my opinion, this is the most important part of the draft for business. The tax authority will not be able to simply write “splitting” in a report.
- The tax authority applies to a special State Tax Service commission, which within 30 working days gives an opinion on whether there are signs of abuse.
- If there are, the taxpayer is sent a notice listing the operations. He has 45 days to provide explanations and documents.
- An inspection order can be issued no earlier than 120 days after the notice. The inspection lasts up to 18 months, with a possible extension of another 12.
- The report must contain a description of the operations, evidence that the tax advantage was the main purpose, a justification of artificiality, and a calculation.
- Objections are considered by other members of the commission. The taxpayer may involve up to two experts of his own and representatives of the Ministry of Finance. If the commission finds the facts insufficient, no liabilities are determined for those operations.
The burden of proving abuse lies with the tax authority, and a PPR issued following such an inspection can be appealed in the usual way.
When it will take effect
If the Verkhovna Rada adopts the law, it will take effect on 1 January 2028. Laws have no retroactive effect unless they mitigate liability (Article 58 of the Constitution).
So operations carried out before that date must be assessed under today’s rules.
For me, the main signal here is not even the rates. The state acknowledges that to requalify a business’s operations, a clear rule, a separate procedure, and proven artificiality are needed. Today, the Tax Code has none of these.
3. If the draft law is adopted, BEB cases will get a basis in tax norms
Today, splitting cases rest on a calculation of “how it would have been if the business were a single taxpayer.” Article 212 of the Criminal Code refers to the Tax Code, and the Tax Code has no provision that would allow several FOPs to be combined for taxation.
Draft Law No. 16150 adds exactly what is missing: a tax provision. It does not change Article 212 of the Criminal Code, so the BEB will keep all its criminal tools and will gain what it lacks today.
What exactly the investigation will get
- a statutory definition of tax abuse and artificiality;
- a direct rule: artificial operations are disregarded, and taxes are calculated according to the real substance of the relationship;
- separate provisions for FOPs: the obligation to move to the general system and a single tax of 18% on funds received as a result of abuse;
- a PPR issued after the commission’s opinion.
Instead of an analytical report, the investigation will have an officially determined tax liability, which is a completely different level of evidence.
What this means for networks
For structures that genuinely operate as one business, the criminal risk will increase. The defense’s main argument today, that the Tax Code does not give the right to “merge” FOPs, will disappear for new periods.
And the 2,555-day period means that more years of operation will come under review.
The BEB will find it hard to bypass the new procedure
Tax abuse will be established not by the investigation but by the tax authority: a commission opinion, 45 days for explanations, at least 120 days before the order, and an inspection of up to 18 months.
When the Tax Code has a special procedure for establishing precisely these facts, it will be much harder for the BEB to ignore it. The defense will be able to point to it as the proper procedure for such inspections.
If the investigation calculates “losses” bypassing this procedure, the case will have no basis in tax norms. And if the commission finds the facts insufficient, there will be no liabilities for these operations, and therefore no subject of evasion.
And only for new periods
The new provisions will apply to operations from 1 January 2028. Until then, cases will rest on today’s shaky foundation, and I do not expect there to be fewer of them in 2026-2027.
So the draft law gives the BEB what it lacks today: a tax provision. But along with the provision come a procedure, time limits, and a burden of proof on the tax authority, and the defense in future cases will rest on exactly these.
4. Which decisions a business can make right now
The cheapest defense begins months before a search, and with the new rules, even years before an inspection. If your business operates through several FOPs, I advise the following order.
- Look at your structure through a detective’s eyes. Take the list of signs from the first section and honestly count how many apply to you. Several matches are a reason for an audit, not for panic.
- Record a real business reason for each FOP. A separate outlet, a separate line of business, a partner with their own share, a franchise: these are understandable grounds. They must be visible in the documents: contracts, their own suppliers, their own accounts, and decisions. Under the draft law, it is valid commercial reasons that will distinguish a lawful structure from an artificial one. Documents created now will carry more weight than explanations written after a notice from the tax authority.
- If in substance the business is one, restructure the model before 2028. Moving to an LLC or to the general system for the main turnover is a decision you make yourself and at your own pace now. After a search or a commission notice, you will no longer have that luxury.
- Prepare your people. Outlet managers, the accountant, and the FOPs themselves must know what to do during an actual inspection or search, whom to call, and that they have the right not to testify against themselves and their close relatives (Article 63 of the Constitution). In splitting cases, it is often staff testimony that becomes the main evidence.
- If a case already exists, do not pay the first amount named. First find out what the calculation rests on: an inspection and a PPR, or an analytical report. A PPR should be appealed in the administrative court, because it directly affects the criminal case. And if the liability is real, remember: release from liability through reimbursement under Part 4 of Article 212 of the Criminal Code works under the current law only before a notice of suspicion is served.
Splitting is not a crime until it is proven that one business stands behind several FOPs and that there was intent not to pay taxes. But the state has already decided that such structures will be under close scrutiny, and the draft law on tax abuse is already in the Verkhovna Rada.
So the best moment to look at your structure is before a detective does it.
